After the Regular Season completes, the teams are usually divided into two categories:
- “A” Division
- “B” Division
The teams will have a playoff game (if applicable) and the winners will meet on Championship Saturday (aka “Super Saturday”) to determine the Champions.
| Season | First Place | “A” Champion | “B” Champion |
| 2023 | Nineteen Plus Bombers (8-4-0) | Nineteen Plus Bombers | Bandits |
| 2022 | Volunteers (7-1-0) | Tigers | Brick City Bombers |
| 2021 | Volunteers (7-1-0) | Bandits | Brick City Bombers |
| 2019 | Volunteers (10-2-0) | Volunteers | Bandits |
| 2018 | Volunteers (8-2-1) | Rage | Brick City Bombers |
| 2017 | Volunteers (14-3-0) | Raiders | Brick City Bombers |
| 2016 | Dub Squad (10-1-0) | Rage | Bandits |
| 2015 | Raiders (11-0-0) | Raiders | Rage |
| 2014 | Raiders (16-0-0) | Raiders | Hawks |
| 2013 | Little Caesars Outlaws (17-2-0) | Raiders | Ice Men |
| 2012 | Raiders (19-0-0) | Raiders | Mustangs |
| 2011 | Raiders (16-2-0) | Raiders | Rage |
| 2010 | Raiders (18-0-0) | Raiders | Greener & Sons Army |
| 2009 | Raiders (15-2-0) | Raiders | Ten Pennies |
| 2008 | Raiders (11-0-0) | Raiders | Steelers |
| 2007 | Raiders (14-0-0) | Raiders | Ten Pennies |
| 2006 | Raiders (16-1-2) | Raiders | The Force |
| 2005 | Raiders (17-1-1) | Raiders | Steelers |
| 2004 | Raiders (19-1-0) | Little Caesars Outlaws | Steelers |
| 2003 | Raiders (20-0-0) | Raiders | Little Caesars Outlaws |
| 2002 | Raiders (21-0-0) | Raiders | Little Caesars Outlaws |
| 2001 | Raiders (21-0-0) | Raiders | Steelers |
| 2000 | Raiders (14-1-0) | Raiders | Bills |
| 1999 | Raiders (21-0-0) | Bone Crushers | Steelers |
| 1998 | Raiders (19-2-0) | Raiders | Trojans |
| 1997 | Raiders (18-2-0) | Raiders | Trojans |
| 1996 | Raiders (20-0-0) | Raiders | Bone Crushers |
| 1995 | Raiders (20-0-0) | Raiders | The Ave |
| 1994 | Raiders (18-0-0) | Raiders | Trojans |
| 1993 | Oilers (14-0-0) | Oilers | Ten Pennies |
| 1992 | Raiders (17-0-0) | Oilers | Kooler Kings |
| 1991 | Raiders (14-0-1) | Raiders | Trojans |
| 1990 | Raiders (11-0-0) | Raiders | Ten Pennies |
| 1989 | Three Mile (12-2-2) | Three Mile | Kooler Kings |
| 1988 | Trojans (12-2-0) | Three Mile | Walking Wounded & Sons |
| 1986 | Unknown | Speedy Gas Tank | Kooler Kings |
| 1982 | Unknown | Runner’s World | Walking Wounded & Sons |