| Season | Scoring | Sacks | Interceptions |
| 2023 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (85) | Peter Stoner (22) | Kevin Keenan (7) |
| 2022 | Brandon Cormier (63) | Peter Stoner (24) | Mike Sampel (10) |
| 2021 | Luke O’Grady (49) | Devon Bradbury (17) | Luke O’Grady (6) |
| 2019 | Andrew Ewart (78) | Andrew Ewart (12) | Luke O’Grady (9) |
| 2018 | Andrew Ewart (57) | Andrew Ewart (20) | Adam Forstner (6) |
| 2017 | Dan Smith (139) | Andrew Ewart (27) | Tom Harris (14) |
| 2016 | Tim Jackson (78) | Peter Stoner (21) | Graeme Brown & Jim Mather (8) |
| 2015 | Dustin Curran (70) | Peter Stoner (17) | Josh Brown (10) |
| 2014 | Chris Boyce (152) | Peter Stoner (39) | Jim Mather (37) |
| 2013 | Chris Boyce (191) | Peter Stoner (46) | Jim Mather (23) |
| 2012 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (138) | Giuliano Debortoli (41) | Darren Lavigne (26) |
| 2011 | Andrew Hamilton (145) | Giuliano Debortoli (31) | Jim Mather (21) |
| 2010 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (146) | Dan Arseneau (39) | Jim Mather (33) |
| 2009 | Jim Mather (105) | Randy Gilmore (45) | Dwight Kyle (24) |
| 2008 | Jim Mather (116) | Darnell Hogan (35) | Jim Mather (16) |
| 2007 | Mike Thaoms (190) | Chris Arseneau (36) | Jim Mather (17) |
| 2006 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (165) | Darnell Hogan (46) | Darren Lavigne (23) |
| 2005 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (127) | Dan Arseneau (59) | Jim Mather (23) |
| 2004 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (149) | Dan Arseneau (49) | Darren Lavigne (23) |
| 2003 | Doug MacPhee (169) | Tony Hogan (52) | Darren Lavigne (24) |
| 2002 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (139) | Tony Palmer (78) | Jim Mather (27) |
| 2001 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (181) | Tony Hogan (46) | Jim Mather (30) |
| 2000 | Mike Gillespie (105) | Mike O’Reilly (24) | Jim Mather (17) |
| 1999 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (208) | Steve Anderson (44) | Jim Mather (30) |
| 1998 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (157) | Tony Hogan (53) | Jim Mather (28) |
| 1997 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (154) | Tony Hogan (48) | Jim Mather (22) |
| 1996 | Peter McIntyre (130) | Tony Hogan (83) | Jim Mather (22) |
| 1995 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (178) | John Brown (50) | Sean Chamberlain (20) |
| 1994 | Ken Lawrence Jr. (146) | Tony Hogan (59) | Carl Olsen (19) |
| 1993 | Dan Eadle & Ken Lawrence Jr. (122) |
Tony Hogan (45) | Chris Legault & Mike Sampel & Glen Smith (13) |
| 1992 | Brendon Carson (162) | Tony Hogan (77) | Glen Smith (19) |
| 1991 | Peter McIntyre (147) | Tony Hogan (73) | Glen Smith (14) |
| 1990 | Brendon Carson & Roger Moses (94) |
Tony Hogan (47) | Brendon Carson (14) |
| 1989 | Bruce Harding (127) | John Brown (48) | Brendon Carson (15) |
| 1988 | Tom O’Reilly (145) | Paul Cunningham (45) | Dan Eadle (14) |
